Jebediah – Jimmy Eat World – split – Review

Jebediah/ Jimmy Eat World

split (Big Wheel Recereation)
by Tim Den

Boy are those JEW guys active these days… First the Singles collection, now this split, soon to be followed by a full-length… Good for them. We need as much Jimmy Eat World as we can get, particularly to show bands like Jebediah how it’s really done. Hailing from Australia (and apparently a double-platinum act there. What did you expect from the country that spawned Silverchair?), Jebediah tries really hard not to sound like a wimpy Nirvana crossed with Sixpence None The Richer (yes, that Christian AOR group who sings “Kiss Me,” and whose mesmerizing cutie female singer I’ve dedicated my life to pursuing [figuratively]), but gives it away by writing six minute pop tunes that should’ve been under three. It’s already a bad idea to milk the same verse/chorus three times in one song, but somehow Jebediah have convinced themselves that the listener needs to hear the repetition seven times. With hardly any variations. Played at a mid-tempo to drag everything even further into oblivion. Oh, and did I mention there’re no variations? Just thought I’d point that out because either I’m slowly losing my sanity from listening to this, or they really meant to sing one hook – the same way, over and over – longer than I take a shower.

Do yourself a favor: get this, play the living crap out of the three Jimmy Eat World songs (which, as always, are heavenly slices of melancholy drowned in ear-candy instrumentation, topped with yearning/crooning so evocative it almost surpasses the vocals on Clarity), but stay away from tracks three to six. Unless you like Sixpence None The Richer for their music.
(325 Huntington Ave. #24 Boston, MA 02115)